That is the question.

Have any clues? Opinions? Hard evidence that Colby was reconned / not retconned?

Has our Guildenstern to David's Rosencrantz always been a spy? Post them here!

Over the summer hiatus, I want to figure out if it's possible to make a case that Colby Granger wasn't retconned! At least, by the end of the summer I want to have a firm grasp on the realities of the situation. (Unlike so many other things, I never have a firm grasp on. Little, unimportant things, like reality!)

We're a smart fandom people! We can figure out the truth!