Famester Dish:

I had to go with SYTYCD. As much as I love AI, it's much easier to - well, "fake" isn't exactly the word I'm looking for but it'll have to do in a pinch - fake being a passable singer than it is to fake being a good dancer. AI seems to rely more on personalities than pure talent, and attracts more of the famewhore type. A lot of the contestants on SYTYCD have been dancing since they were children and it's really what they want to do, whereas a lot of AI contestants simply want to use the show to launch themselves into any kind of entertainment-based career.

That said, I'd take Simon, Paula, and Randy over Nigel, Mary and Random Guest Judge any day. However, it's a tie between Ryan and Cat. *g*

Having danced for most of my life I am obviously drawn to this show. Plus Seacrest sounds like nails on a chalkboard to me, I always did like that other dude from the first season better....

I was litteraly at the gym one day on the tredmill when I noticed this show was sarting, I tripped fell off the back of it, brushed myself off and ran home as fast as possible so as not to miss anything. I am a bit bored with the ballroom though, no offense, it is beautiful but there are already a ton of other ballroom shows on, ok one, and it isn't technically on right now, but you get the idea.

I don't even want to talk about Rockstar, boo. And Boy SHakira/Boy Britney is the only thing entertaining about America's GOt Talent. Dear God I watch too much TV.